Cash Vs Tangible rewards
| Cash rewards |
Tangible rewards |
| Purely an extrinsic motivator with little emotional involvement; does not provide lasting satisfaction and long-term performance stimulation |
Carry a significant trophy value thus continue to reinforce the good performance and behaviors
|
| Creates expectations, leads to entitlement and consequently looses its motivating value
|
Provide tangible symbol of achievement and serve as an encouragement to other employees
|
| A rupee is a rupee; participant attaches no greater emotional or inspirational value to cash. Lacks emotional impact of tangible rewards; thus quickly spent and forgotten |
Reinforce the association with sponsor company and thus increase loyalty |
| No "trophy" value to be a constant reminder and continue to motivate. It is difficult to show off; thus limits the lasting impact of the reward
|
Provide guilt-free enjoyment of reward thus increase the motivating impact |
| Difficult to target a particular behavior because of the lacking association with a particular achievement |
Both extrinsic and intrinsic motivators; provide strong emotional appeal to participants' personal wants and interests |
| Recipients often can't recall what they purchased with cash reward which further diminished its impact |
Carry a higher perceived value because of the increased emotional attachment; therefore, stimulate performance better than cold cash
|
| Minimal association with sponsor company due to minimal trophy value of reward which minimizes the potential of goodwill toward the company
|
Can be attached to a particular behavior thus stimulating a specific response in a long term |
| Not cost-effective; requires three times the incentive investment compared to non-cash, on average |
Participant's family is involved in selecting and sharing awards thus multiplying the emotional value of the reward and its impact on the participant
|
|
Usually spent on necessities thus lacking a positive association with the targeted accomplishment or behavior
|
Provide a 3-to-1 return on investment compared to cash. On average, cash programs cost 12 cents per incremental dollar netted by increased performance, versus 4 cents per dollar for non-cash programs
|
| Participant feels guilty for not spending a cash award on necessities which taints the reward with unpleasant feelings
|
Do not become an expected part of an employee income or an entitlement; always seen as a reward for a particular accomplishment or performance
|